Living in Southwest Florida means plenty of sunny days and backyard lounging—but it also means battling bugs, humidity, hurricanes, and UV damage. If your pool enclosure is showing signs of wear and tear, you might be wondering: should I repair just a few screen panels, or fully rescreen the entire structure?
In this guide, we’ll help you weigh your options based on cost, durability, and long-term benefits. Whether you’re in Naples, Marco Island, Estero, Bonita Springs, or Cape Coral, this decision can impact both your comfort and your home’s value.
When a Simple Repair Makes Sense
If your screen enclosure is still fairly new and just a few panels are damaged—perhaps from a branch, a pet, or accidental tears—then a partial repair might be the way to go.
Signs You May Only Need Repairs:
- Less than 25% of your panels are torn or loose
- The screen frame is still in good condition
- You’re using standard fiberglass screen, and matching it is easy
- You’re not ready to invest in a full upgrade
At Best Rescreen Company, we regularly perform single-panel replacements or sectional repairs for customers in Bonita Springs and Marco Island who just need a quick fix to get their lanai or pool cage back in shape.
Why Full Rescreening May Be the Smarter Move
While repairs work in the short term, sometimes it’s more cost-effective to rescreen the whole enclosure—especially if your current screen is more than 6–8 years old or you’re dealing with several problem spots.
Reasons to Consider a Full Rescreen:
- Widespread wear – faded, brittle, or discolored screen throughout
- Mismatched patches – new screens look obvious next to older panels
- Better materials available – such as Super Screen or Florida Glass
- Structural upgrades – if you’re replacing bolts, fasteners, or support pieces
We often tell clients in Estero and Cape Coral that if more than half of their screens are damaged, it’s time to start fresh. The cost per square foot of a full rescreen is actually cheaper than repeated spot repairs—and you won’t be calling us back every few months.
Cost Comparison: Repair vs. Rescreen
Here’s a quick breakdown to help you understand the math.
| Service | Avg. Cost Range (varies by size) |
|---|---|
| 1–3 Panel Repairs | $150–$300 |
| Full Rescreen (standard screen) | $1,200–$2,500+ |
| Upgrade to Super Screen | Add ~25–35% more upfront |
While the full rescreen looks pricier at first, you’ll gain more years of durability—and fewer headaches—especially if you’re dealing with insects, pets, or Florida storms.
Choosing the Right Material
Another reason full rescreening is often the better option: you get the chance to upgrade your screen material. Best Rescreen Company offers:
- Super Screen: Tear-resistant and long-lasting
- No-See-Um Screen: Keeps out tiny bugs common in Cape Coral and Bonita Springs
- Florida Glass: Great for privacy and wind protection
- Solar Shield (SunTex®): Blocks heat and UV rays, perfect for Estero homes
Once you compare the benefits of these premium options to basic fiberglass, many customers choose to fully rescreen and never look back.
What About Time and Mess?
A typical full rescreen takes 1–2 days, depending on the size of your enclosure. Our team removes the old screen, disposes of the waste, and installs your new material with minimal disruption. We clean up thoroughly—your lanai or pool area will look brand new.
Repairs are faster (usually same-day), but when you’ve got lots of issues, the process becomes more fragmented and frustrating over time.
Bottom Line: Which Should You Choose?
If your screen is fairly new and the damage is isolated, then repairing just the affected panels might be fine for now. But if your screen is showing its age, or you’re looking to improve appearance, strength, and comfort, then a full rescreen is usually the smarter investment—especially in Florida’s coastal climate.
Serving All of Southwest Florida
At Best Rescreen Company, we’ve been repairing and rescreening patios, lanais, and pool enclosures since 1993. We proudly serve:
- Naples
- Marco Island
- Bonita Springs
- Estero
- Cape Coral
- Fort Myers
…and surrounding areas.
📍Visit us at:
5660 Strand Ct Unit A244, Naples, FL 34110
📞 Call today: (239) 344-7774
🌐 Website: www.bestrescreenco.com
Ready for a Quote?
Don’t wait for the bugs—or storms—to take over.
Contact us today for a free estimate. Whether you need a quick repair or want to upgrade your entire enclosure, we’ll help you decide what’s best for your home and budget.
