If you’ve noticed a tear or hole in one section of your pool cage, you might be asking yourself: “Do I have to replace the whole thing?” The good news is — no, you don’t. In many cases, you can rescreen just one panel.
At Best Rescreen Company in Naples, FL, we get this question all the time from homeowners in Marco Island, Bonita Springs, Estero, and Fort Myers. This article breaks down when it makes sense to replace one panel and when a full rescreen might be the better option.
When Replacing One Screen Panel Makes Sense
Here are the most common situations where replacing a single panel is a practical and cost-effective option:
1. Isolated Damage
If only one panel is ripped due to a storm, pet damage, or flying debris, it makes perfect sense to replace just that one panel. It’s quick, affordable, and avoids unnecessary labor.
2. Newer Screens
If your enclosure was recently screened and the rest of it is in great condition, there’s no reason to spend money on the entire structure. One panel replacement will restore your screen’s function and appearance.
3. Budget Concerns
A single panel replacement is the most budget-friendly repair option. We often recommend this route for clients in Cape Coral and Bonita Springs who want to stretch the life of their screen enclosure until a full replacement is needed.
When You Might Want to Rescreen the Whole Structure
Although a one-panel fix sounds ideal, it’s not always the best long-term move.
1. Multiple Tears or Old Screens
If your cage has several panels with damage or if the screen is brittle and discolored, replacing just one panel can look odd. A full rescreen ensures your enclosure looks fresh and matches throughout.
2. Screen Age Over 10 Years
Most screens last about 8–12 years depending on exposure to sun, salt air, and rain. If you live near the coast in Marco Island or Estero, you’ve probably seen screens wear out faster due to harsher elements. In this case, it’s smarter to plan for a full rescreen.
3. Mismatched Materials
If the original screen type isn’t available anymore, or if a new panel sticks out due to color difference or mesh pattern, the fix might look worse than the original issue. We always aim to match materials, but sometimes a full update is the only way to get a clean, consistent result.
What’s the Process for Replacing a Single Panel?
At Best Rescreen Company, our process is quick and straightforward:
- We inspect the entire structure to ensure there’s no hidden damage.
- We remove the damaged screen and clean the frame.
- We install a new, matching screen using professional-grade spline and materials.
- We test for tightness and visual consistency.
Whether you live in Naples, Bonita Springs, or Fort Myers, we can usually complete a one-panel job in under an hour.
Can You DIY a One-Panel Rescreen?
Technically yes — but we don’t usually recommend it. Here’s why:
- Most DIYers don’t have access to high-quality screen materials or the right tools, like spline rollers and professional spline.
- Poor tension during installation can lead to sagging screens or fast wear.
- One mistake can tear the new screen or damage the aluminum frame.
If you’re in Naples, FL or anywhere nearby, it’s worth calling a pro. Our team gets the job done fast, right, and for less than you might expect.
Panel Repair Is a Smart Short-Term Fix
If your pool cage has one damaged section and the rest looks great, go ahead and fix just that panel. It’s a smart, efficient choice — and we’re here to help.
However, if you’ve had multiple panel failures in a short period, or if the entire cage is over a decade old, you might be due for a full rescreen. It’ll save you from patching holes again and again, and it boosts your home’s appearance and value.
Need Screen Repair in Southwest Florida? We’ve Got You Covered.
We proudly serve:
- Naples
- Bonita Springs
- Marco Island
- Estero
- Fort Myers
- Cape Coral and nearby areas
📍 Best Rescreen Company
5660 Strand Ct Unit A244
Naples, FL 34110
📞 (239) 344-7774
🌐 www.bestrescreenco.com
Whether it’s one panel or a full rescreen, we’ll get your lanai or pool cage back in top shape.
📞 Call (239) 344-7774 or visit www.bestrescreenco.com today to schedule your free estimate.
