When your pool cage screens start showing signs of wear, many homeowners in Naples, Marco Island, Bonita Springs, Estero, and surrounding areas ask the same question: Should I repair a few panels or go for a full rescreen? It’s a fair question—and the right answer depends on a few key factors like screen age, damage extent, budget, and long-term plans for your property.
Let’s break it down so you can make the best decision for your Florida home.
What is Pool Cage Screen Repair?
Screen repair involves replacing just the damaged or torn panels. This is usually a good option when:
- Only a few screens are ripped or loose
- The rest of the cage structure and screens are still in good shape
- You want a quick, budget-friendly fix
Pros:
- Lower immediate cost
- Quick turnaround time
- Keeps most of the existing materials intact
Cons:
- The new screen sections may not match the color or wear of older screens
- If screens are brittle or aging, others may fail soon after
- Not ideal if you plan to sell or renovate the home
What is a Full Rescreen?
A full rescreen means replacing all the mesh panels across your entire pool cage or lanai. This is recommended when:
- Screens are 8+ years old and showing wear across multiple sections
- There’s fading, sagging, or sun damage throughout
- You want a uniform, fresh look
- You’re upgrading to stronger or specialty screen material
Pros:
- Everything is new and consistent
- Enhances curb appeal—great if you’re selling or remodeling
- Stronger materials like Super Screen or Florida Glass can be used
- Better long-term value
Cons:
- Higher upfront cost
- Takes a little longer than minor repairs
Screen Lifespan in Southwest Florida
Here in Naples, the weather isn’t always kind to our enclosures. Constant sun, storms, and humidity take a toll. Most standard fiberglass screens last 6–10 years, but materials like Super Screen or Pet Screen can stretch that lifespan to 15+ years.
If you’re in Bonita Springs, Estero, or Marco Island, and your screens were installed over a decade ago, chances are you’re due for a full rescreen—even if only a few panels are currently damaged.
Matching Screen Material and Color
One issue that surprises homeowners is the color mismatch between new and old screens. Even if you’re just replacing a few panels, the fresh screen will look noticeably different next to the older, faded mesh. Over time, this can make your enclosure look patchy or neglected.
If you care about a clean, consistent look—especially for rental or resale properties—a full rescreen may be the better route.
Budget Considerations
Repairing individual panels can run as low as $75–$150 depending on the size and material.
Full rescreens, on the other hand, generally start around $1,200 and go up depending on the size of your enclosure and choice of screen.
But remember—doing repairs again and again can add up quickly. Many homeowners we work with in Southwest Florida choose full rescreens because it saves them the hassle (and money) of ongoing repairs.
When to Choose a Full Rescreen
Choose a full rescreen if:
- Your screen is more than 8–10 years old
- You notice multiple weak spots or holes
- You’re planning to sell or rent out your property
- You want to upgrade to premium screen types
- You’re tired of chasing patchwork repairs
Choose a panel repair if:
- Damage is limited to 1–3 screens
- Screens are less than 5 years old
- You’re looking for a quick, low-cost solution
Get Expert Advice Before You Decide
Still not sure which option is best for your home? That’s where we come in. At Best Rescreen Company, we offer free estimates and honest recommendations based on your situation—not sales pressure.
We’ve proudly served Naples, Marco Island, Bonita Springs, Estero, and surrounding areas for years. Whether you need a quick patch or a full enclosure refresh, our team delivers top-notch service and long-lasting results.
📍 Contact Information:
Best Rescreen Company
5660 Strand Ct Unit A244, Naples, FL 34110
📞 (239) 344-7774
🌐 www.bestrescreenco.com
Ready to get your pool cage looking like new again? Whether you need a quick repair or a full rescreen, our team is here to help.
Call Best Rescreen Company today at (239) 344-7774 or visit www.bestrescreenco.com to schedule your free estimate. Let’s bring back the beauty—and protection—of your outdoor space.
